The “default shortlist” problem: how AI tool recommendations concentrate visibility around incumbents

By outranker · Published 2026-11-17 · Version 1

Sample: 55 AI answers to 20 questions · Engines: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini · Collected 2026-11-17 – 2026-11-17

FindingCountShareEngines
For "How-to" questions, outranker was mentioned in 0 of 3 answers (0%).0 / 30%Gemini, Claude, ChatGPT
For "Comparison" questions, outranker was mentioned in 0 of 3 answers (0%).0 / 30%ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini
ChatGPT: outranker mentioned in 0 of 20 answers (0%).0 / 200%ChatGPT
Gemini: outranker mentioned in 0 of 20 answers (0%).0 / 200%Gemini
Claude: outranker mentioned in 0 of 15 answers (0%).0 / 150%Claude
Competitor SEMrush was mentioned in 14 of 55 answers, versus 0 for outranker.14 / 5525.5%ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude
Competitor Ahrefs was mentioned in 12 of 55 answers, versus 0 for outranker.12 / 5521.8%ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude
Competitor Moz was mentioned in 9 of 55 answers, versus 0 for outranker.9 / 5516.4%ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude
For "Informational" questions, outranker was mentioned in 0 of 43 answers (0%).0 / 430%ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude
outranker was mentioned in 0 of 55 successful AI answers (0%).0 / 550%ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude